CryptoMist Logo
FeaturedBy CryptoMist Editorial TeamPublished

Adam Schiff and Eight Senators Push CFTC to Scrap Kalshi Geofence Order

Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff ask the CFTC to withdraw its Nov. 5 prediction market order, citing a Kalshi geofence conflict with courts.

Adam Schiff and Eight Senators Push CFTC to Scrap Kalshi Geofence Order

What to Know

  • Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff asked CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on Nov. 16 to withdraw his agency's Nov. 5 prediction market interpretation
  • The CFTC's Release 9323-26 gives designated contract markets 30 days to end domestic geographic access restrictions or explain why they cannot comply
  • A federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence tribal lands in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi just hours before the CFTC's Nov. 5 release
  • The agency must respond by Nov. 23, and ranking member Amy Klobuchar could push the fight into a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing

The CFTC is catching heat from nine Democratic senators who want the agency to walk back a Nov. 5 order they say punches a hole through state gambling law. Sen. Adam Schiff of California, joined by Amy Klobuchar and seven colleagues, told Chairman Michael Selig in a Nov. 16 letter that his interpretation of the impartial access rule is effectively pushing prediction markets to defy judges in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and California. The demand is simple: pull the interpretation, or at least freeze it while the courts sort it out. Their deadline for a response is Nov. 23.

Senators Call Selig's Order a Collision With State Courts

The senators did not soften the language. 'Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,' they wrote. The target is CFTC Release 9323-26, titled 'CFTC Issues Impartial Access Requirements Interpretation,' published on Nov. 5, 2026 and running in the Federal Register at 91 FR 72407. According to the CFTC release, designated contract markets, the registered venues where event contracts trade, must stop domestic geographic restrictions that violate Commission Regulation 38.151(b) within 30 days or explain to the Division of Market Oversight why they cannot.

Selig was blunt. 'Geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with those purposes and the Act's impartial access requirements,' he said in the release, arguing derivatives markets have to run on a 'uniform basis at a national scale.' The senators read that as a federal agency telling private platforms to ignore state judges. Klobuchar, ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee that oversees the CFTC, is the heaviest name on the letter after Schiff. Also signing: Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell, Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Patty Murray and Gary Peters.

Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed.

Nine Democratic senators, Nov. 16 letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig
Kalshi illustration for Adam Schiff and Eight Senators Push CFTC to Scrap Kalshi Geofence Order

What Does the Senators' Letter Actually Demand?

Answer first: pull the interpretation, pause it, or narrow it. The top ask is a full withdrawal. If that fails, the senators want the CFTC to hold the interpretation in abeyance while the state-level lawsuits play out. If even that fails, they want three carve-outs confirmed in writing: location blocks a judge orders, blocks required by the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act or a tribal-state compact, and blocks an exchange decides to put up on its own. The letter also tells the agency to preserve records going back to Jan. 1, 2025, and to reply by Nov. 23.

The argument leans on two federal appeals courts. Both the Sixth and Ninth Circuits have ruled that state gambling law still reaches event contracts, even on federally registered exchanges. The geofences the CFTC wants dismantled, the senators say, exist because judges demanded them. 'The Commission now appears to be encouraging prediction markets to offer prohibited contracts in contempt of these court orders during active litigation,' they wrote.

  • Withdraw the Nov. 5 interpretation entirely
  • Or hold it in abeyance during active litigation
  • Or confirm judge-ordered, tribal-compact, and voluntary geoblocks remain lawful
  • Preserve records back to Jan. 1, 2025
  • Respond in writing by Nov. 23

The Kalshi Case That Makes the Timing Look Bad

Here is the part that stings. Hours before the CFTC published Release 9323-26, a federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence around tribal lands in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi. The senators say that sequence 'raises concerns that the Commission may be coordinating with platforms currently engaged in litigation,' effectively pushing those platforms to walk away from the very geofences a federal judge just imposed.

That is the kind of accusation that does real damage if it sticks. The CFTC did not mention Kalshi or Blue Lake in its Nov. 5 release. It did not have to. The practical effect, read against that timeline, is federal cover for Kalshi to argue there is a conflict between a district court injunction and an agency interpretation. Which is a much better fight for a prediction market lawyer than a straight contempt motion.

Selig's War With State Attorneys General

The letter did not land in a vacuum. The CFTC and the Justice Department sued Arkansas after its attorney general sued Kalshi. They sued Louisiana on Nov. 13. And on Nov. 16, the same day the senators' letter hit his inbox, Selig posted on X that he 'will not allow states to file lawsuits against our exchanges unchecked.' He did not mention the letter. He did not need to. Both statements are the same fight: who sets the rules for prediction markets, Washington or the state capitals?

Adam Schiff has been pressing Selig for months on contracts tied to physical injury, death and war. This letter widens his coalition to nine. Two of the signers, Cantwell and Padilla, represent Washington and California, states whose courts are directly cited in the complaint. That overlap is not a coincidence. Senators do not usually attach their names to a procedural complaint about an impartial access interpretation. They do when a judge in their own state has already ruled.

Where Does Crypto Fit Into This Mess?

Prediction markets ride crypto's regulatory coattails more than most traders realize. Kalshi and Polymarket settle in dollars, not tokens, but the 'uniform national market' argument Selig is defending is downstream of the same fight spot crypto exchanges have been losing against state regulators for years. If the CFTC holds the line here, the precedent cuts both ways for crypto derivatives. If a federal judge forces the agency to climb down, state attorneys general get a template for going after spot crypto venues the same way.

The tape is not celebrating any of this. Total crypto market capitalization sat at roughly $2.17 trillion at 11:00 UTC on Nov. 17, down 2.65% on the day, with Bitcoin dominance at 59.18% and Ethereum dominance at 10.04%, according to CoinGecko. The Crypto Fear and Greed Index from alternative.me printed 12, 'Extreme Fear', barely above yesterday's reading of 10. Regulatory wins do not get priced in during tape like that. They get fought over in court.

What Happens If the CFTC Refuses to Budge?

The agency has until Nov. 23 to answer. Three scenarios, ranked by likelihood. One: Selig acknowledges the letter, declines to withdraw, and treats the 30-day compliance window as administrative rather than prescriptive. Two: the senators refer the issue to the Senate Agriculture Committee for a formal hearing, which Klobuchar as ranking member has the standing to push. Three: a plaintiff in one of the state cases moves to enforce the court injunction against a designated contract market that drops its geofence, forcing a direct collision between an agency interpretation and a federal district court order.

Scenario three is the one Kalshi's lawyers are drawing up contingencies for. A contempt motion in Northern California against a federally registered exchange would blow a hole in the uniform national market thesis the CFTC has bet this interpretation on. It would also be the clearest test yet of whether event contracts are commodities under federal jurisdiction or gambling under the states'. Selig says commodities. Courts in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and California keep saying gambling.

Selig told the market it would run on a national basis. Nine senators just told him it will not. Now they both wait for a judge to break the tie.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the CFTC's Nov. 5 prediction market order?

The CFTC's Nov. 5 interpretation, Release 9323-26, tells designated contract markets they must end domestic geographic access restrictions within 30 days under Commission Regulation 38.151(b), the impartial access rule, or justify why they cannot. Chairman Michael Selig argues derivatives markets must operate uniformly at a national scale.

Why do nine senators want the CFTC order withdrawn?

The senators argue the order forces prediction market exchanges to defy existing federal court injunctions in Michigan, Nevada, Washington and two California tribal cases. They say it undermines state gambling law and the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, and raises questions about whether the CFTC is coordinating with Kalshi during active litigation.

What is Kalshi's role in the Blue Lake Rancheria case?

A federal court in Northern California ordered Kalshi to geofence around Blue Lake Rancheria tribal lands just hours before the CFTC issued its Nov. 5 interpretation. The senators argue that timing raises concerns the agency may be nudging Kalshi to abandon the geofence the court just imposed.

What does Adam Schiff want from CFTC Chairman Michael Selig?

Sen. Adam Schiff wants Chairman Michael Selig to pull the Nov. 5 interpretation or at least pause it during litigation. Schiff also wants the CFTC to confirm that judge-ordered, tribal-compact, and voluntary geographic blocks remain lawful. The agency must respond to the senators by Nov. 23.

Sources and primary references

Market figures in this article were read on 2026-11-17 11:00 UTC. Data: CoinGecko, Derivatives data: Binance USDT-M futures, Sentiment: alternative.me Crypto Fear & Greed Index, TVL: DefiLlama. Prices move; check a live source before acting.